Taste the Best that Surprise you
Reynolds Seafood delivers a menu rooted in classic Southern seafood comfort. The standout for me was the Fried Fish Platter, golden and crispy, with a tender flake inside-served generously alongside hush puppies and a heaping portion of coleslaw. For shellfish lovers, the Shrimp Basket doesn’t disappoint; the shrimp are lightly battered and full of flavor, especially when paired with their tangy house-made dipping sauce.
One of the most popular items is the Seafood Combo Plate, which lets you mix and match fish, shrimp, oysters, or scallops-perfect if you want a bit of everything. I also appreciated the Crab Cakes, which are rich with real crab meat and only lightly seasoned to let the seafood shine.
For those looking for something grilled instead of fried, the Grilled Tilapia offers a lighter option, served with rice and steamed vegetables. Sides like fried okra, mac and cheese, and potato salad round out the Southern charm. If you're not into seafood, they also offer classics like chicken tenders and hamburgers, but it’s the ocean-inspired dishes that truly steal the show.
Everything feels homemade, hearty, and satisfying-exactly what you'd expect from a down-home North Carolina seafood joint.